Friday, August 21, 2009

A Twilight...


If you have a television or computer, you have heard of Twilight. A novel series by Stephenie Meyer, the Twilight series chronicles a "forbidden" love affair between a vampire and a human girl. I read the books, and did enjoy them. But there are a few reasons that I find the pop culture's over-the-top, seizing obsession with them a bit concerning.

1) Evil is Sexualized. Vampires in the Twilight series are tied to their blood lust. While the Cullen coven seeks to abstain from feeding on humans (a good plot choice by Meyer), it is a temptation that is not actively quelled. Edward is constantly telling Bella that he yearns, desires, LUSTS after her blood. The evil is thereby sexualized, and although he never ends up killing her, the harm has been done. The Bible reminds us in 2 Corinthians that we "take captive every thought to make it obedient to Christ." Obviously, the series is not "Christian" and cannot, therefore, be expected to abide by Christian commands, but the principle remains. If Edward truly wished to free himself from his blood lust, he would not invite Bella into his sexualized fantasy.

2) Evil is Glorified. If Meyer wanted a true hero in her novels, she should have kept Bella a human. The vampiric lifestyle is an evil one, a point stressed by Meyer again and again. But then our heroine becomes one? That is an unoriginal cop out. Because the evil is sexy, alluring, and promises immortality, we eventually want Bella to become the very thing that, throughout the novels, comes close to destroying her. For Meyer to allow that to happen is to follow the romantic and sexual intrigue of the story, as opposed to having her character stand up for what is right.

3) Evil is Overlooked: Bella is a character totally lacking in depth. Once Edward enters her life, he swallows her identity (which, up to that point, had only been outlined in a few sentences about her being quiet and clumsy) . He is God to her, the person for whom she lives and breathes. This masochistic self-denial (which leads Bella to ignore her own safety and well being) offers us a glimpse into the complete opposite of a healthy relationship. Love, for Bella, requires that she forfeit her family, her values, her conscience, all in order that she devote herself more fully to Edward. If Edward was a character who knew what real love meant, he would never have allowed Bella the freedom to throw away her life as she does. Real love has natural limitations: until both parties realize that they serve God first, they cannot fully serve each other. Additionally, Jacob (Bella's friend and eventual werewolf) represents another love temptation for Bella. Really? Were Bella so overtly in love with Edward, as Meyer seems to indicate, wouldn't it be contradictory to introduce another love interest? Yet it remains so. Jacob is a man who tempts Bella to deny her love for Edward and follow a human life. It would seem the healthier option, but Edward wins out in the end, making Jacob's contribution to the novels nothing more then a sexually charged intrusion.

I know these points may seem rather serious, given that Twilight is a fictional series. But the obsessive following the books (and ensuing films) have garnered has been enough to turn the Twilight novels into a cult phenomenon. Girls swoon at the thought of Edward luring them into the dark, vampiric dream. Obviously, wishing for a vampire boyfriend can do nothing but harm. A violent and lustful creature, whose very life is consumed by an overwhelming desire to kill humans, should not be an idol for young girls today.

But that is exactly what is happening.

5 comments:

Unknown said...

Another AWESOME write-up, Sarah. Spot on. You and I have discussed this a number of times, but it's so true. It seems because of this series vampires have become re-popularized and frankly, it's disturbing. There's nothing good about them.

I love reading your thoughts! Keep it up.

When does your book get released? :-)

A. said...

Hey Sarah,
This is Alysha from Covenant. I wanted to say that I really enjoyed your blog on Twilight! I too have read the books and did enjoy them...I even own them, but I have thought over the past few months that the obsession over them is disturbing. Thank you for an honest, spiritual defense as to why these book are not the healthiest choices out there.
I'm aspiring to write fantasy myself and hearing thoughts like that remind me how careful I need to be and how spiritually grounded in Christ I need to be before publishing a piece of fiction.
:-) I miss you being around Covenant! I hope you're doing well!

A. said...

Hey Sarah,
This is Alysha from Covenant. I wanted to say that I really enjoyed your blog on Twilight! I too have read the books and did enjoy them...I even own them, but I have thought over the past few months that the obsession over them is disturbing. Thank you for an honest, spiritual defense as to why these book are not the healthiest choices out there.
I'm aspiring to write fantasy myself and hearing thoughts like that remind me how careful I need to be and how spiritually grounded in Christ I need to be before publishing a piece of fiction.
:-) I miss you being around Covenant! I hope you're doing well!

A. said...

Hey Sarah,
This is Alysha from Covenant. I wanted to say that I really enjoyed your blog on Twilight! I too have read the books and did enjoy them...I even own them, but I have thought over the past few months that the obsession over them is disturbing. Thank you for an honest, spiritual defense as to why these book are not the healthiest choices out there.
I'm aspiring to write fantasy myself and hearing thoughts like that remind me how careful I need to be and how spiritually grounded in Christ I need to be before publishing a piece of fiction.
:-) I miss you being around Covenant! I hope you're doing well!

A. said...

Hey Sarah,
This is Alysha from Covenant. I wanted to say that I really enjoyed your blog on Twilight! I too have read the books and did enjoy them...I even own them, but I have thought over the past few months that the obsession over them is disturbing. Thank you for an honest, spiritual defense as to why these book are not the healthiest choices out there.
I'm aspiring to write fantasy myself and hearing thoughts like that remind me how careful I need to be and how spiritually grounded in Christ I need to be before publishing a piece of fiction.
:-) I miss you being around Covenant! I hope you're doing well!